Radical VermontMad River Valley
The celebration opens in:— d— h— m— sTo July 8, 2027

HomeResearchThe Lyon–Griswold Brawl (1798)

Revision 1 · 2026, September 17 · History →

Event

The Lyon–Griswold Brawl (1798)

The Lyon–Griswold brawl was a two-part quarrel between Representatives Matthew Lyon of Vermont and Roger Griswold of Connecticut that occupied the U.S. House of Representatives for nearly four weeks in early 1798. On January 30, in Philadelphia's Congress Hall, Griswold taunted Lyon about his Revolutionary War record and Lyon spat tobacco juice in his face.1 After the House failed to expel Lyon, Griswold attacked him at his desk on February 15 with a hickory cane, and Lyon defended himself with a pair of fire tongs.21 On February 23 the House voted 73 to 21 not to expel either man.2 The fight was fixed in public memory by an anonymous etching, Congressional Pugilists.3

Dates
January 30 – February 23, 1798
Place
Congress Hall, Philadelphia (House chamber, Fifth Congress)
Principals
Matthew Lyon (Vermont); Roger Griswold (Connecticut)
Presiding
Speaker Jonathan Dayton (New Jersey)
First incident
January 30 — Griswold’s "wooden sword" remark; Lyon spits in his face
Second incident
February 15 — Griswold canes Lyon; Lyon answers with fire tongs
House action
Reprimand and expulsion of Lyon both fail, February 12; expulsion of both Members rejected 73–21, February 23
Outcome
Both Members keep their seats

Background

The House of 1798 sat in Philadelphia, and its divisions were hardening faster than its rules. The House Historian's account of the affair notes that it "revealed emergent political factionalism in the House at a time when formal parties had yet to fully form."2 Underneath the personal quarrel was a policy one: Griswold supported the Adams administration's hard line toward France and its military preparations, while Lyon believed that preparing for war would eventually bring war on.2

Lyon was an Irish immigrant, and his Revolutionary War service carried a stain his opponents could reach for: he had been cashiered from the Continental Army, allegedly for cowardice.1 The House, for its part, had no precedent for disciplining a Member. It had only the constitutional provision allowing it to expel a Member for "disorderly Behaviour" by a two-thirds vote.1

Chronology

January 30, 1798 — The wooden sword

The House is balloting to choose the Members who will manage the impeachment of Senator William Blount of Tennessee, the first impeachment proceeding in the country's history. While the clerks count, Speaker Jonathan Dayton leaves the chair and sits at a desk on the floor. Near the fireplace behind him, Lyon and Samuel Dana of Connecticut are trading words "rather warmer than usual." Dayton warns them: "Gentlemen, keep yourselves cool. If you proceed much further you will want seconds."1

Lyon moves to the bar of the House and, at a volume meant to carry, disparages the Connecticut delegation and suggests its constituents are gullible. Roger Griswold approaches, smiling, and tells him: "If you go into Connecticut, you had better wear your wooden sword." Lyon does not react. Griswold repeats it. Lyon rears back and spits in his face.1

Griswold does not retaliate on the spot. A motion is soon introduced to expel Lyon for his "violent attack and gross indecency," and the House creates a seven-member Committee of Privileges to take testimony.1

February 1, 1798 — Lyon's letter

A letter from Lyon is read to the House. His defense is technical: the House stood in recess, the Speaker was out of the chair, and business had halted for the count. If he broke the rules, he writes, "it is owing wholly to my ignorance of their extent, and that the House claimed any superintendence over its members when not formally constituted."1

February 2, 1798 — The committee recommends expulsion

Abraham Venable of Virginia reports for the Committee of Privileges. It finds the conduct of "Spitting Matt," as he has come to be called, "highly indecorous, and unworthy of a member of this House," and recommends that Lyon be expelled. Nathaniel Macon of North Carolina objects to the haste and wins time for the full House to weigh the evidence: "The punishment that the report proposed was equal to death itself."1

February 2–12, 1798 — The debate

The question consumes most of the next six legislative days and fills some 75 pages of the Annals of Congress with debate and witness testimony. Macon complains that he has heard "as many illiberal expressions in the course of this debate as he had ever heard," and that the House, arguing in front of reporters, has failed to keep "these things out of the sight of the world."1

February 12, 1798 — Expulsion fails

Macon proposes a reprimand in place of expulsion; the motion fails. The motion to expel Lyon follows at once. It wins a majority, but not the two-thirds the Constitution requires. Lyon keeps his seat.1

February 15, 1798 — The cane and the tongs

The House has opened with prayer but has not yet been called to order. Lyon is seated at his desk, writing. Griswold walks up carrying a stout yellow hickory cane and begins to strike him. Wedged between chair and desk, Lyon takes some twenty blows before he can get free.1

The two struggle in front of the Speaker's chair, then around it into a narrow passage along the outer wall. Lyon seizes the tongs from the fireplace and, in the Historian's word, the men begin to joust. They go down — witnesses disagree whether Griswold threw Lyon or Lyon tripped — and Members move to separate them. Some are in no hurry. When two New York Members each take one of Griswold's legs to drag him off, Speaker Dayton objects: "That is not a proper way to take hold of him. You ought to take hold of him by the shoulders." Jonathan Havens answers that "it would not hurt him to pull him a foot or two on the carpet."1

They are parted. Minutes later they find improvised weapons and go at each other again before finally being subdued. Hinds' Precedents records that the "affray … was with difficulty stopped."1

February 16, 1798 — A motion to expel them both

Thomas Terry Davis of Kentucky moves to expel both Members, arguing that "neither the dignity, the honor, or peace of the House could be preserved whilst these members remained in it." Josiah Parker of Virginia seconds: "If these members were not expelled, no member could consider himself as safe in his seat." The question goes back to the Committee of Privileges. Under a resolution passed by a wide majority — and the threat of custody under the Sergeant at Arms — Lyon and Griswold stand at their desks and pledge before the Speaker to keep the peace.1

February 20–23, 1798 — The House lets it go

Having taken sworn testimony from ten witnesses, the committee reports on February 20 and recommends that neither man be expelled. On February 23, after rejecting a motion to postpone the matter to the last day of the Congress, the House accepts the recommendation, 73 to 21. It then narrowly declines even to consider censure.12

Aftermath

Newspapers along the seaboard reprinted the official accounts, and the satirists followed. The best known image, the anonymous etching Congressional Pugilists, is inscribed "Congress Hall, in Philada. Feb. 15, 1798" and shows the two mid-swing, cane against tongs, before a gallery of grinning colleagues; later states of the plate identify Speaker Dayton, the Clerk and the Chaplain among the onlookers, and a picture of fighting cocks labelled "Royal Sport" hangs on the chamber wall.34 Its caption runs:

He in a trice struck Lyon thrice
Upon his head, enrag'd sir,
Who seiz'd the tongs to ease his wrongs,
And Griswold thus engag'd, sir.3

A Frederick, Maryland magazine, The Key, set the whole affair to the tune of "Yankee Doodle" as "The Battle of the Wooden Sword! Or, the Modern Pugilists."1

James Madison, a year out of the House, thought the episode a disgrace and saved his sharpest words for Griswold, who had let a committee handle what the code of honor said he should have settled himself: "No man ought to reproach another with cowardice, who is not ready to give proof of his own courage."1

For Lyon the brawl was a beginning rather than an end. He was already the only Democratic-Republican in Congress from New England and the Federalists' most conspicuous target; that October he became the first person tried and convicted under the new Sedition Act, and that winter he was re-elected from his jail cell.56

Legacy

The House Historian reads the House's inaction — first against Lyon, then against Griswold — as a product of the founding generation's honor culture: gentlemen, not institutions, were expected to police gentlemen. That expectation probably delayed any formal system of discipline. More than thirty years passed before the House first formally disciplined a Member, censuring William Stanbery of Ohio in 1832 for insulting the Speaker.1

The etching outlived the argument. Impressions are held by the Library of Congress, the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the House's own collection, and it remains the image by which both men are known.34

Sources & external links

  1. 1Wooden Sword, Spitting Lyon (Whereas: Stories from the People's House) open ↗history.house.gov
  2. 2Representative Roger Griswold of Connecticut attacked Matthew Lyon of Vermont on the House Floor open ↗history.house.gov
  3. 3Congressional Pugilists (anonymous etching, 1798) open ↗Library of Congress (3 states) + Met Museum (open access) + Yale, LCP, Free Library, HSP, Clements, US House
  4. 4Congressional Pugilists (impression) - The Metropolitan Museum of Art open ↗The Metropolitan Museum of Art
  5. 5LYON, Matthew — Biographical Directory of the United States Congress (L000545) open ↗US Congress (Bioguide)
  6. 6Rachlin, 'The Sedition Act of 1798 and the East-West Political Divide in Vermont,' Vermont History 78 open ↗Vermont Historical Society (open PDF)

Cite this entry

The Record is versioned: quote the revision you read. The permalink below survives a rename of the entry’s address, which the address above does not.

Revision
1
Last changed
2026, September 17
APA-ish
Radical Vermont. (2026, September 17). The Lyon–Griswold Brawl (1798). The Record, Radical Vermont. Revision 1. https://radicalvermont.org/record/id/e6b998f5-a6d3-4c11-b9f3-1e29508a51ce
BibTeX
@misc{radicalvermont-lyon-griswold-brawl-1798-r1,
  title        = {The Lyon–Griswold Brawl (1798)},
  author       = {{Radical Vermont}},
  howpublished = {The Record, Radical Vermont},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {9},
  note         = {Revision 1},
  url          = {https://radicalvermont.org/record/id/e6b998f5-a6d3-4c11-b9f3-1e29508a51ce},
}