Where land resistance met revolutionary government
Catamount Tavern
Catamount Tavern, also known as Fay’s Tavern and the Green Mountain House, was an inn and gathering place in Bennington, in what became Vermont. Operated by Stephen Fay, it became closely associated with the Green Mountain Boys’ resistance to New York land claims and with revolutionary government. The wooden building was destroyed by fire on March 30, 1871; its site is marked by a bronze catamount.1234
The establishment combined ordinary hospitality and commerce with political activity. Its remembered defiance of New York is only part of its history: Margaret “Peg” Bowen was enslaved by Fay there during the revolutionary period.15
- Place
- Bennington, present-day Vermont
- Proprietor
- Stephen Fay
- Established
- Circa the 1760s; exact year uncertain
- Associated with
- Green Mountain Boys; Vermont Council of Safety
- Building lost
- March 30, 1871
Fay’s inn and its names
Fay moved from Hardwick, Massachusetts, to Bennington in 1766, according to local historian Bob Tegart. His Green Mountain House served as a store as well as a tavern and inn, supplying household goods, clothing materials and tools. It stood in the older hill settlement, on what is now Monument Avenue.1
Accounts disagree about its construction date. The Vermont Historical Society places it in the middle of the 1760s; Hiland Hall’s nineteenth-century description says shortly before 1770. The later monument bears 1767. A date in the 1760s is therefore safer than treating one commemorative inscription as a building record.234
The famous sign was a stuffed catamount mounted above the tavern. Historical accounts describe the animal facing New York, making the sign a warning to the settlers’ opponents. The exact date when the establishment acquired its familiar Catamount name is less secure than the enduring story of the sign.23
Land claims and resistance
Bennington lay within the disputed New Hampshire Grants. Settlers had obtained land under New Hampshire titles, but the Crown’s 1764 boundary decision placed the territory under New York’s jurisdiction. Overlapping grants and attempts to enforce New York claims threatened the security of those holdings.6
This was a conflict over property, legal authority and political influence. Historian Gary J. Aichele emphasizes the investments of land speculators on both sides, including the Allens. The Green Mountain Boys’ opposition developed through armed resistance and pressure on officials and settlers who recognized New York.7
A meeting place for the Green Mountain Boys
Fay’s tavern provided a gathering place for Ethan Allen, Jonas Fay, Remember Baker and Thomas Chittenden. The Vermont Historical Society identifies its rooms with the organizing of the Green Mountain Boys and, later, the Council of Safety and Vermont’s new government. Here a commercial establishment became part of the infrastructure of a political movement.2
That importance did not make it the movement’s only meeting place. Aichele also identifies opposition meetings at Eliakim Weller’s tavern in Manchester and at Jehiel Hawley’s home in Arlington in 1774. Resistance depended on a network of towns and leaders, rather than on a single room in Bennington.7
The signpost and coercion
The tavern was also remembered as a place where dissent was punished. The Vermont Historical Society recounts the seizure of Dr. Samuel Adams, a New Hampshire grantee who spoke in favor of accommodation with New York. Brought to the tavern and subjected to a proceeding by his opponents, he was tied to a chair and suspended from its signpost while onlookers ridiculed him.6
Aichele includes the episode in his account of the movement’s intimidation of Yorker sympathizers. It shows why the tavern’s political history cannot be reduced to convivial planning among like-minded neighbors: the same movement that resisted dispossession also tried to silence opponents. The story comes through later historical accounts, rather than a trial transcript examined for this article.76
Revolution and the defense of Bennington
Local historical interpretation connects the tavern with preparations for the 1775 expedition against Fort Ticonderoga. It also associates the building with John Stark’s conferences with Vermont leaders before the Battle of Bennington. These accounts establish its remembered role as a meeting and coordination point; they do not supply a record of every order or conversation held there.8
Tegart describes the Council of Safety using the tavern in 1777 to organize the area’s defense and seek help from neighboring states. Its wartime significance was administrative as well as military: leaders needed places to meet, communicate and arrange support.1
The battle’s aftermath reached the surrounding neighborhood. Joseph Parks’s cemetery history places a field hospital behind the tavern and describes wounded men from both sides dying after being brought back toward Bennington. It treats some burial numbers as estimates or oral tradition, rather than as a complete casualty register.9
Margaret “Peg” Bowen
Bennington Museum’s research identifies Bowen as a Black woman enslaved by Fay from 1772 to 1778. Her presence connects the establishment to labor and family histories absent from the familiar image of revolutionary leaders beneath the catamount sign.5
The museum reproduces a receipt dated March 6, 1778, documenting Fay’s sale of Bowen to Charles Phelps for twenty pounds. Jonas Fay witnessed the transaction. This occurred after Vermont’s 1777 constitution had declared against adult slavery. The museum’s account emphasizes the gap between constitutional language and the continued enslavement of people such as Bowen. Her day-to-day experience in Bennington remains poorly documented.5
Fire and commemoration
By the nineteenth century the former tavern had become a private residence. Hall’s account reports that it was unoccupied shortly before the fire of March 30, 1871, whose cause was unknown. Writing of the ruins that autumn, he described surviving chimneys and a fireplace bearing the words Council room. His account preserves evidence about the lost building while also transmitting older traditions about its revolutionary past.3
The replacement catamount belongs to a later commemorative period. The Smithsonian’s sculpture inventory identifies Giuseppe Moretti as sculptor, J. Ph. Rinn as designer and the Henry-Bonnard Bronze Company as founder. It records an 1896 casting and a dedication on June 23, 1897. A separate sidewalk plaque honors Bowen, adding the history of an enslaved resident to a site long associated with political liberty.48
The surviving documentary record extends beyond memorials. Bennington Museum catalogs a bar tab dated 1770–1776 and attributed to Stephen Fay. Such records offer a way to investigate the tavern as a working business alongside its place in Vermont’s political memory.10
Sources & external links
- 1Fay’s Tavern or the Catamount Tavern open ↗Bennington Historical Society / Bennington Museum
- 2Freedom & Unity: Rioters vs. Rebels open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 3The Old Catamount Tavern at Bennington, Vt. open ↗Internet Archive scan via Wikimedia Commons
- 4Catamount Monument (sculpture) open ↗Smithsonian Institution
- 5Peg Bowen: Enslaved at the Catamount Tavern open ↗Bennington Museum
- 6Freedom & Unity: Grants vs. Yorkers open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 7Making the Vermont Constitution: 1777–1824 open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 8Old Bennington walking tour open ↗Bennington Museum
- 9The History of the Old Burying-Ground open ↗Bennington Centre Cemetery Association
- 10Archives & Rare Books: Bartab from the Catamount Tavern, 1770–1776 open ↗Bennington Museum
Cite this entry
The Record is versioned: quote the revision you read. The permalink below survives a rename of the entry’s address, which the address above does not.
- Revision
- Not versioned
- Last changed
- undated revision
- Imported from
- radicalamerica fb730b9
APA-ish
Radical Vermont. (undated revision). Catamount Tavern. The Record, Radical Vermont. radicalamerica fb730b9. https://radicalvermont.org/record/id/37fd26fe-7eb6-4416-bea9-cc44abab32b8
BibTeX
@misc{radicalvermont-catamount-tavern,
title = {Catamount Tavern},
author = {{Radical Vermont}},
howpublished = {The Record, Radical Vermont},
note = {radicalamerica fb730b9; undated revision},
url = {https://radicalvermont.org/record/id/37fd26fe-7eb6-4416-bea9-cc44abab32b8},
}Found a problem?
If a citation doesn’t hold or a fact is wrong, tell us — we would rather hear it from you than print it twice.
File a correction →