From the New Hampshire Grants to the American Revolution
Green Mountain Boys
The Green Mountain Boys were an armed movement of New Hampshire Grants settlers who resisted New York’s authority in the years before the American Revolution. Associated with Ethan Allen, Seth Warner and Remember Baker, they defended land claims through local organization and force, including the intimidation and expulsion of opponents.12 Their gatherings at Bennington’s Catamount Tavern connected that resistance with the expedition that captured Fort Ticonderoga in May 1775; later that year, men recruited from the Grants chose Warner to lead a regiment in American service.345
- Origins
- Resistance to New York’s authority in the New Hampshire Grants, early 1770s
- Associated leaders
- Ethan Allen, Seth Warner, Remember Baker
- Meeting place
- Catamount Tavern, Bennington; other regional meeting places also mattered
- Revolutionary action
- Capture of Fort Ticonderoga, May 10, 1775
- Later military leadership
- Seth Warner, chosen over Allen in 1775
The New Hampshire Grants
The dispute grew from incompatible colonial claims to what became Vermont. New Hampshire created more than a hundred towns west of the Connecticut River, while New York claimed the same territory. On July 20, 1764, the king fixed the boundary between the colonies at the river’s western bank. That jurisdictional decision did not end the conflict over land already granted under New Hampshire authority: New York refused to recognize the earlier titles, and grant-holders organized to resist.8
For families who had established farms, a disputed title threatened their homes as well as their investment. But the struggle also involved substantial land speculation. The Wisconsin documentary history’s introduction emphasizes that the Allen brothers and their associates held extensive speculative interests, and that New Hampshire and New York claimants alike sought financial advantage. The familiar image of farmers confronting outside speculators therefore captures only part of the conflict: rival claims to property and rival claims to government were intertwined.92
Organization and resistance
After attempts at relief through New York’s courts failed, resistance developed through town committees and military companies. A confrontation near Bennington in 1771 helped demonstrate the limits of New York’s power to enforce evictions. Companies organized under leaders including Warner and Baker, with Allen exercising broader authority. Rather than starting with a modern statewide military structure, the movement grew from particular communities defending their claims.6
The Vermont Historical Society describes the early companies as calling themselves New Hampshire Men, while New York authorities called them the Bennington Mob and rioters. By 1772, Green Mountain Boys was an established name. The competing labels expressed the conflict itself: men who saw their actions as defending their property appeared to officials as organized resistance to lawful authority. The local committees and companies supplied a means to mobilize beyond a single farm or town.1
Catamount Tavern and regional meetings
Stephen Fay’s Bennington tavern was one of the places where that movement took political form. Originally called the Green Mountain Tavern, it acquired its familiar name from the stuffed catamount displayed on its signpost in defiance of New York. The Vermont Historical Society identifies Allen, Baker, Jonas Fay and Thomas Chittenden among its political visitors. Its rooms brought together men associated with the Green Mountain Boys and, later, Vermont’s government.3
The tavern was important without being the sole headquarters of every decision. Gary J. Aichele’s history of Vermont’s constitutional beginnings also describes opposition meetings at Eliakim Weller’s tavern in Manchester and Jehiel Hawley’s home in Arlington in 1774. Political organization worked through a network of meeting places, personal connections and towns. Catamount Tavern’s prominence belongs within that wider geography.6
Coercion and the limits of solidarity
Resistance could impose severe costs on people who accepted New York authority. The documentary history describes depositions alleging destroyed houses, damaged crops, beatings, banishment and armed intimidation. The punishment known as the beech seal was corporal violence, not merely a colorful emblem of defiance. New York responded with rewards and, in March 1774, legislation directed against the movement’s leaders, escalating a struggle already marked by threats on both sides.2
Nor did owning a New Hampshire grant guarantee protection from the Boys. The Vermont Historical Society recounts how Dr. Samuel Adams, himself a grant-holder, was punished for sympathizing with New York and criticizing the violence: he was tied into a chair and suspended from the Catamount’s signpost for public ridicule. It also describes the whipping and banishment of Benjamin Hough, a New York justice of the peace. These punishments enforced political loyalty as well as defending titles.9
The expedition to Ticonderoga
The outbreak of war against Britain gave the Grants’ armed organization a new role. Plans to seize Fort Ticonderoga did not originate solely with Allen. John Brown had recommended taking the fort in a March 29, 1775 letter to Massachusetts leaders, saying people of the Grants had undertaken to act if hostilities began. His proposal placed the fort within a larger northern strategy and preceded Lexington and Concord.10
After fighting began, organizers from Connecticut and Massachusetts moved toward the Grants. Fort Ticonderoga’s reconstruction of the expedition places a consultation at Fay’s Tavern in Bennington on May 2: Allen met Edward Mott, James Easton, Brown and others, and agreed to recruit the Green Mountain Boys. Epaphras Bull’s journal, reproduced by the museum, describes the consultation and the dispatch of men to investigate the fort’s condition.4
Further decisions followed at Castleton. Mott’s account, reproduced by the museum, describes a May 8 council dividing responsibilities among officers and assigning Allen, Easton and Warner their places in command. Recruitment, intelligence, boats and coordination all mattered. The expedition relied on cooperation across colonial boundaries as well as the local men Allen and his associates could raise.4
On May 10, Allen and Benedict Arnold led the party that captured Ticonderoga. Arnold carried a Massachusetts commission and disputed Allen’s authority; their agreement to lead together did not settle who would command afterward. Fort Ticonderoga’s account draws on Mott and Arnold’s memorandum book to show the argument continuing inside the captured fort. Loyalty to Allen helped keep the recruits together, but it also complicated the attempt to establish a recognized military command.7
From local movement to American service
Congress addressed the Boys on June 23, 1775. It recommended collecting the names and expenses of men involved in taking and holding the lake forts so that they could be paid. It also recommended that New York, in consultation with General Philip Schuyler, employ the Green Mountain Boys under officers of their own choosing. The resolution joined practical recognition of their service with an arrangement for recruitment and command.11
Schuyler’s July 3 letter to John Hancock warned against treating the Boys as an unlimited reserve. He explained that the name was applied broadly to inhabitants of the Grants, many of whom needed to remain at work supporting their families. Men who had helped capture and garrison Ticonderoga had already returned home. His letter makes clear why a regional name, an armed political movement and a regiment’s actual strength cannot simply be treated as identical.12
When a regiment was organized in 1775, the men chose Warner rather than Allen as their commander. Allen nevertheless accompanied the northern invasion as a civilian scout and was captured during an unsuccessful attempt against Montreal. His resulting imprisonment kept him out of much of the war until 1778. Later military achievements associated with the Green Mountain Boys therefore require attention to Warner’s command rather than assuming Allen personally led them throughout.5
Hubbardton and Bennington
In July 1777, American forces withdrew from Ticonderoga and Mount Independence. Warner, Ebenezer Francis and Nathan Hale commanded a rear guard that encountered pursuing British and German troops at Hubbardton on July 7. This was part of the continental campaign against Burgoyne’s advance, involving units and commanders beyond the original Grants resistance.13
The Battle of Bennington on August 16 likewise belonged to a coalition. Fought at Walloomsac in New York, it involved forces under John Stark and Warner and unfolded in two engagements. Later pension testimony reproduced in New York’s battlefield study describes Warner’s Continental regiment arriving against British reinforcements and helping militia recover their position. The American victory denied Burgoyne badly needed supplies. Warner’s regiment and the state militia were distinct bodies fighting in the same coalition.1415
History and memory
The Green Mountain Boys’ story bridges a local land struggle and the Revolutionary War, but its most familiar narrative was shaped after the events. Fort Ticonderoga notes the influence of Allen’s 1779 captivity narrative on popular memory and places Brown’s earlier proposal alongside it. Reading those accounts together restores a wider cast of organizers and competing perspectives. It also leaves room to recognize military service without erasing the coercion directed at neighbors during the land dispute.109
Sources & external links
- 1Freedom & Unity: The Green Mountain Boys open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 2The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, vol. XXIX: Vermont introduction open ↗Wisconsin Historical Society Press; University of Wisconsin–Madison Libraries
- 3Freedom & Unity: Rioters vs. Rebels open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 4The Expedition to Ticonderoga open ↗Fort Ticonderoga
- 5Ethan Allen open ↗National Museum of the United States Army
- 6Making the Vermont Constitution: 1777–1824 open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 7Who’s in Command at Fort Ticonderoga? open ↗Fort Ticonderoga
- 8New Hampshire: Consolidated Chronology of State and County Boundaries open ↗The Newberry Library
- 9Freedom & Unity: Grants vs. Yorkers open ↗Vermont Historical Society
- 10John Brown March 29, 1775 open ↗Fort Ticonderoga
- 11Journals of the Continental Congress: June 23, 1775 open ↗The American Founding
- 12Philip Schuyler to John Hancock, July 3, 1775 open ↗Naval Documents of the American Revolution digital project
- 13Delaying Burgoyne: Hubbardon Battlefield open ↗National Museum of the United States Army
- 14Bennington battlefield American primary sources, part 1 open ↗New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation
- 15Bennington Battlefield State Historic Site open ↗National Park Service
Cite this entry
The Record is versioned: quote the revision you read. The permalink below survives a rename of the entry’s address, which the address above does not.
- Revision
- Not versioned
- Last changed
- undated revision
- Imported from
- radicalamerica 49d2e8e
APA-ish
Radical Vermont. (undated revision). Green Mountain Boys. The Record, Radical Vermont. radicalamerica 49d2e8e. https://radicalvermont.org/record/id/cf9914eb-811f-4570-b713-59949932ae2c
BibTeX
@misc{radicalvermont-green-mountain-boys,
title = {Green Mountain Boys},
author = {{Radical Vermont}},
howpublished = {The Record, Radical Vermont},
note = {radicalamerica 49d2e8e; undated revision},
url = {https://radicalvermont.org/record/id/cf9914eb-811f-4570-b713-59949932ae2c},
}Found a problem?
If a citation doesn’t hold or a fact is wrong, tell us — we would rather hear it from you than print it twice.
File a correction →