Featured · Event
United States v. Lyon (1798)
United States v. Lyon was the first prosecution and conviction under the Sedition Act of 1798.
On July 14, 1798, with war fever against France running high, President Adams signed the Sedition Act, criminalizing "false, scandalous and malicious" writing against the federal government, Congress, or the President. Matthew Lyon — Irish-born, formerly an indentured servant, founder of Fair Haven, and the only Democratic-Republican member of Congress from all of New England — was already the Federalists’ most despised target: earlier that year he had spat at Connecticut’s Roger Griswold and defended himself with fireplace tongs when Griswold attacked him with a cane on the House floor, the first physical brawl in House history.
“Vermont itself was politically split east–west, and the Federalist establishment saw in Lyon the Act’s ideal first defendant.”
At a glance
- Court
- U.S. Circuit Court, District of Vermont (Rutland)
- Presiding
- Justice William Paterson, U.S. Supreme Court (riding circuit)
- Charge
- Seditious writing under the Sedition Act of 1798
- Verdict
- Guilty (October 1798)
- Sentence
- $1,000 fine plus costs; four months’ imprisonment (Vergennes jail)
- Defendant’s plea
- Act unconstitutional; publications innocent; contents true
- Outcome
- Served in full; re-elected from jail; fine refunded with interest by Act of Congress, July 4, 1840 (6 Stat. 802)
Sources cited in this entry
- Matthew Lyon, Re-elected to Congress from Jailnewenglandhistoricalsociety.com
- Rachlin, 'The Sedition Act of 1798 and the East-West Political Divide in Vermont,' Vermont History 78Vermont Historical Society (open PDF)
- The life of Representative Matthew Lyon of Vermont and Kentuckyhistory.house.gov
- An Act to refund a fine imposed on Matthew Lyon (6 Stat. 802, Ch. XLV)US GPO / govinfo
- An Act for the Punishment of Certain Crimes (Sedition Act of 1798), 1 Stat. 596US Statutes at Large
- Representative Roger Griswold of Connecticut attacked Matthew Lyon of Vermont on the House Floorhistory.house.gov
- LYON, Matthew — Biographical Directory of the United States Congress (L000545)US Congress (Bioguide)
- Lyon letter, Spooner's Vermont Journal, July 31, 1798Readex Early American Newspapers / AAS
- The Scourge of Aristocracy and Repository of Important Political TruthsAAS / Readex Early American Imprints (WorldCat OCLC 3408985)
- Vergennes Gazette trial coverage & jail letters, Oct 1798Readex / AAS
- Jefferson to Madison, Nov. 3, 1798LOC Madison Papers / Founders Online
- Bushnell, 'Then Again' - column on Matthew LyonVTDigger
- New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964)Justia