Featured · Event
The Lyon–Griswold Brawl (1798)
The Lyon–Griswold brawl was a two-part quarrel between Representatives Matthew Lyon of Vermont and Roger Griswold of Connecticut that occupied the U.S. House of Representatives for nearly four weeks in early 1798.
The House Historian reads the House’s inaction — first against Lyon, then against Griswold — as a product of the founding generation’s honor culture: gentlemen, not institutions, were expected to police gentlemen. That expectation probably delayed any formal system of discipline. More than thirty years passed before the House first formally disciplined a Member, censuring William Stanbery of Ohio in 1832 for insulting the Speaker.
The etching outlived the argument. Impressions are held by the Library of Congress, the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the House’s own collection, and it remains the image by which both men are known.
“That expectation probably delayed any formal system of discipline.”
At a glance
- Dates
- January 30 – February 23, 1798
- Place
- Congress Hall, Philadelphia (House chamber, Fifth Congress)
- Principals
- Matthew Lyon (Vermont); Roger Griswold (Connecticut)
- Presiding
- Speaker Jonathan Dayton (New Jersey)
- First incident
- January 30 — Griswold’s "wooden sword" remark; Lyon spits in his face
- Second incident
- February 15 — Griswold canes Lyon; Lyon answers with fire tongs
- House action
- Reprimand and expulsion of Lyon both fail, February 12; expulsion of both Members rejected 73–21, February 23
- Outcome
- Both Members keep their seats
Sources cited in this entry
- Wooden Sword, Spitting Lyon (Whereas: Stories from the People's House)history.house.gov
- Representative Roger Griswold of Connecticut attacked Matthew Lyon of Vermont on the House Floorhistory.house.gov
- Congressional Pugilists (anonymous etching, 1798)Library of Congress (3 states) + Met Museum (open access) + Yale, LCP, Free Library, HSP, Clements, US House
- Congressional Pugilists (impression) - The Metropolitan Museum of ArtThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
- LYON, Matthew — Biographical Directory of the United States Congress (L000545)US Congress (Bioguide)
- Rachlin, 'The Sedition Act of 1798 and the East-West Political Divide in Vermont,' Vermont History 78Vermont Historical Society (open PDF)